In Part I of Understanding the Law, we established that the Law of God, as given by God to Moses, is best understood as a type of instructional case law. The Law takes principles of wisdom and then wraps them in specific, circumstantial commands, which were relevant and applicable to Israel. However, though the Law is aimed in application toward Israel, the principles that underwrite each law are universally wise and good, even outside of Israel. When we left off, we asked from where these principles derive. That will be the subject of this article.
The Law as Revelation
The underlying principles of the Law are derived from the God who gave them. At Sinai, Moses did not come to write the Law after many days considering the natural order of the world. He did not create or stumble upon it. The Law was given and commanded to Moses by God (Ex. 20:1). The principles from which it was derived must inherently come from God Himself and must be a reflection of His own perfect and eternal character. The principles that undergird the circumstantial specifics of God’s Law are eternal and immutable since God is eternal and immutable.
God’s Law is derived from and built from His own good character. Christians can universally agree that moral laws, such as “you shall not murder” (Ex. 20:13), are eternally binding. The point of confusion arises when this logic is applied across the three aforementioned categories: moral, civil, and ceremonial laws. This is understandable, for numerous passages in the New Testament speak of the abrogation of certain Mosaic laws, namely those we might classify as ceremonial (Gal. 2:16), and Paul frequently appears to speak of the Law in a way that might easily lead one to dismiss its timelessness outright, but even in such instances, he is usually only a few sentences removed from general praise and commendation of the Law. The only way to reconcile these perceived tensions, then, is to understand that such “abrogations” are in circumstance only, and not in principle.
What is meant by circumstance? This refers to the contextual details and specifics in which a law is given. For example, “Do not muzzle an ox while it treads out the grain” (Deut. 25:4) is a case law command regarding the care of an animal while it labors. Yet this law is built upon an underlying principle that might find a wide range of circumstantial applications. This universal underlying principle is what many refer to as its “general equity,” simply meaning the broader principle at play which might find application in any number of circumstances. This is precisely how the Apostle Paul is able to use that very specific and seemingly unrelated law to apply to the care and payment of pastors (1 Tim. 5:17-18). His intention is not to reintroduce the Law in its original circumstantial form, but to apply its general equity, which finds its origins in the character of God.
Similarly, it can be asserted that the ceremonial laws requiring the shed blood of an animal for the remittance of sins are circumstantial in their giving, but that the principle, that God requires blood atonement for sin, is eternal. Today God still requires an atonement of blood for sin, but this law and expectation is fulfilled in new circumstances, namely faith in the perfect sacrifice of Christ. The circumstances of specific Mosaic laws might have “passed away,” but their general equity has not.
The Mosaic Law, in its circumstantial form, was given to the nation of Israel once they entered into a covenant with God. The Lord revealed His character to them through the practical circumstances of the Law, but it was always His intention for Israel to be more than mere lawkeepers; He desired that their lives would be transformed by its teaching. The circumstances of the given Law were unique to them. Clearly, not every nation was appointed to serve as priests. Only Israel enjoyed this blessing. It is nevertheless inescapable that the principle of the Law and its expectations were universal, for they conform first and foremost to the character of God.
The nations were not commanded to play the same role as Israel, but they suffered the weight of judgment for their sin, and without atonement, they were rightly and justly punished. This is how Isaiah can speak of the condemnation of the nations who “transgress God’s Law” (Isaiah 24:5), or how the Lord can warn Israel to keep the Law, lest they be found guilty as the Canaanites were guilty (Lev. 18:24-25). It is the general equity of the Law that is revealed in creation and knowable throughout creation. On these grounds, Paul condemns the whole Gentile world (Rom. 1:18-32). Unfortunately, sin obfuscates our ability to rightly discern such realities, so we must look to the Law for understanding.
How do we rightly divide and apply the Law? We will consider that in Part III of our series.
God’s Law is derived from and built from His own good character. Christians can universally agree that moral laws, such as “you shall not murder” (Ex. 20:13), are eternally binding. The point of confusion arises when this logic is applied across the three aforementioned categories: moral, civil, and ceremonial laws. This is understandable, for numerous passages in the New Testament speak of the abrogation of certain Mosaic laws, namely those we might classify as ceremonial (Gal. 2:16), and Paul frequently appears to speak of the Law in a way that might easily lead one to dismiss its timelessness outright, but even in such instances, he is usually only a few sentences removed from general praise and commendation of the Law. The only way to reconcile these perceived tensions, then, is to understand that such “abrogations” are in circumstance only, and not in principle.
What is meant by circumstance? This refers to the contextual details and specifics in which a law is given. For example, “Do not muzzle an ox while it treads out the grain” (Deut. 25:4) is a case law command regarding the care of an animal while it labors. Yet this law is built upon an underlying principle that might find a wide range of circumstantial applications. This universal underlying principle is what many refer to as its “general equity,” simply meaning the broader principle at play which might find application in any number of circumstances. This is precisely how the Apostle Paul is able to use that very specific and seemingly unrelated law to apply to the care and payment of pastors (1 Tim. 5:17-18). His intention is not to reintroduce the Law in its original circumstantial form, but to apply its general equity, which finds its origins in the character of God.
Similarly, it can be asserted that the ceremonial laws requiring the shed blood of an animal for the remittance of sins are circumstantial in their giving, but that the principle, that God requires blood atonement for sin, is eternal. Today God still requires an atonement of blood for sin, but this law and expectation is fulfilled in new circumstances, namely faith in the perfect sacrifice of Christ. The circumstances of specific Mosaic laws might have “passed away,” but their general equity has not.
The Mosaic Law, in its circumstantial form, was given to the nation of Israel once they entered into a covenant with God. The Lord revealed His character to them through the practical circumstances of the Law, but it was always His intention for Israel to be more than mere lawkeepers; He desired that their lives would be transformed by its teaching. The circumstances of the given Law were unique to them. Clearly, not every nation was appointed to serve as priests. Only Israel enjoyed this blessing. It is nevertheless inescapable that the principle of the Law and its expectations were universal, for they conform first and foremost to the character of God.
The nations were not commanded to play the same role as Israel, but they suffered the weight of judgment for their sin, and without atonement, they were rightly and justly punished. This is how Isaiah can speak of the condemnation of the nations who “transgress God’s Law” (Isaiah 24:5), or how the Lord can warn Israel to keep the Law, lest they be found guilty as the Canaanites were guilty (Lev. 18:24-25). It is the general equity of the Law that is revealed in creation and knowable throughout creation. On these grounds, Paul condemns the whole Gentile world (Rom. 1:18-32). Unfortunately, sin obfuscates our ability to rightly discern such realities, so we must look to the Law for understanding.
How do we rightly divide and apply the Law? We will consider that in Part III of our series.
About The Author
AUSTIN ROUSE
1689 Federalism | Post Millennialism | General Equity Theonomist
Austin Rouse is the Pastor of Families and Students at Southern Heights Baptist Church in Russellville, KY, where he and his wife, Addie, reside with their two children, Naomi and Tommy. He graduated from Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary in fall 2023 with his BA in Biblical Studies and is on track to graduate with his M.Div in the fall of 2024. Austin shepherds Southern Heights in the areas of family worship and discipleship, mission strategization, corporate worship, and student ministry, and co-hosts The Council podcast with a fellow elder of the church.
1689 Federalism | Post Millennialism | General Equity Theonomist
Austin Rouse is the Pastor of Families and Students at Southern Heights Baptist Church in Russellville, KY, where he and his wife, Addie, reside with their two children, Naomi and Tommy. He graduated from Midwestern Baptist Theological Seminary in fall 2023 with his BA in Biblical Studies and is on track to graduate with his M.Div in the fall of 2024. Austin shepherds Southern Heights in the areas of family worship and discipleship, mission strategization, corporate worship, and student ministry, and co-hosts The Council podcast with a fellow elder of the church.
Posted in Christian Living
Posted in Mosaic Law, Law, Torah, Pentateuch, Prophets, Judges, Israel, Wisdom
Posted in Mosaic Law, Law, Torah, Pentateuch, Prophets, Judges, Israel, Wisdom
Recent
Archive
2024
May
IVF is Evil.Find Your WhyWhy Do We Struggle with Self-Control?Old Time ReligionThe Pastor and His BibleLessons from Jude Pt. 4: The Dreams of False TeachersJoining with Creation: Why Your Praise Matters to GodChrist is Worthy of a Healthy ChurchBiblical Discernment and Why It Is NecessaryWhat is the Point of the Bible?Faith Cometh: First Mention Basics of Faith Pt. 2
June
July
Is God For Us?What Laws Are We Supposed to Obey?Remember MeDying Thoughts of a Godly ManOn Justification through Faith Alone in Christ AloneHigh Strangeness and a Christian ResponseDiscovering Perfect FaithfulnessChildren: The Best Bible School for AdultsThe Trembling PastorUnderstanding the Law: Part I
September
Rest In ChristFive Minutes for the Imago DeiUnderstanding the Law: Part IIThe Privilege of Knowing God TrulyEphesians: Abounding Riches of GracePrayer and Providence: A Look At Mark 7:24-30The Love of GodEphesians: Our Inheritance, Hope, and Glory in ChristThe Immutability of GodFighting Sin by Trusting in the Superior Satisfaction
Categories
Tags
17th Century
70 A.D.
Abandonment
Actions
Adam
Adoption
Angels
Animosity
Antinomianism
Anxiety
Assurance
Atonement
Attributes of God
Attrition
Augustine of Hippo
Awe
Baptism
Batman
Belief
Betrayal
Bible Reading
Bible School
Bible Study
Bigfoot
Bitterness
Blame
Blandina
Bravery
Business
Busyness
C.S. Lewis
Calvinism
Camaraderie
Catechism
Ceremonial Law
Challenges
Change
Chants
Chaos
Character
Charlatans
Charles Spurgeon
Children
Choice
Chords
Christology
Church Officer
Circumstances
Civil Law
Clash of the Titans
Claude Ramsey
Clefs
Commandments
Commentary
Communion
Composers
Confession
Contentment
Conversion
Conviction
Coram Deo
Corporate Worship
Creation
Cryogenics
Culture
Death
Decree
Defamation
Dementia
Demons
Dependance
Desire
Devastation
Diligence
Disagreement
Discernment
Discipleship
Discipline
Disobedience
Doctrines of Grace
Doctrine
Dreams
Drudgery
Ecclesiology
Elect
Embryo Grading
Emotionalism
Encouragement
Endor
English Puritanism
Entrepreneurship
Ephesians
Ethnomusicology
Eugenics
Eusebius
Evangelicalism
Evangelism
Evangelist
Evil
Exhortation
Expectations
Fables
Failure
Fairy Tales
Faithfulness
Faithlessness
Faith
False Teachers
Families
Family Worship
Famine
Fasting
Fear
Fellowship
Fertilization
Fervor
Five Points
Forgiveness
Form
Foster Care
Function
Fuxs Counterpoint
Gatherings
Gathering
Gentiles
Gentleness
George Whitefield
Ghosts
Giants
Glory
God's Word
Goodness
Good
Gospel Mission
Gospel
Grace
Gratitude
Greek Mythology
Grief
Happiness
Hardship
Help
Herodotus
Heroes of Renown
Heroes
Homeschooling
Hope
Human Trafficking
Humility
Humphrey Bogart
Hypocrites
IVF
Identity
Idolatry
Immutability
In Vitro Fertilization
Incan Empire
Inheritance
Intellectualism
Israel
James White
Jason and the Argonauts
Jerusalem
Jews
John Calvin
John Frame
John Knox
Joy
Judaism
Jude
Judges
Justification
Kids
Knowledge
Law
Laziness
Learning
Legalism
Legend
Life
Light
Liturgy
Local Church
Love
Luke Bryan
Malak
Marcus Aurelius
Marriage
Martyrdom
Matthew Henry
Meditation
Memory.
Mercy
Minds
Molech
Monergism
Money
Monotony
Moral Law
Morality
Mosaic Law
Mothman
Motivation
Music Theory
Musical Education
Musical Notation
Musicology
Music
Mystery
Mysticism
Myth
Nations
Neglect
Nephilim
Nervousness
New Covenant
Nick Needham
Notes
Obedience
Old Covenant
Old Testament
Omniscience
Online
Order
Orthodox Jew
Pain
Parents
Pastor
Paul The Apostle
Paul Washer
Peace
Pentateuch
Persecution
Perseverance
Plagiarism
Politics
Pornography
Power
Praise
Prayer
Praying
Preacher
Preaching
Preparation
Pride
Priest
Privilege
Prophesy
Prophets
Providence
Psalms
Pulpit Ministry
Punishment
Purification
Purpose
Qualification
Questions
Quick Wit
Reality Shows
Reconciliation
Redemption
Reflection
Reformed Evangelism
Regeneration
Regulative Principle
Religion
Rememberance
Repentance
Responsibility
Rest
Revelation
Reverence
Revival
Reward
Rhetoric
Richard Baxter
Riches
Righteousness
Roman Empire
Romans
Rome
Sabbath
Sacrifice
Sacrificial System
Saints
Salvation
Sanctification
Sarcasm
Satisfaction
Self-Control
Self-Discipline
Self-Examination
Sermon Preparation
Serpent
Service
Sex Selection
Shame
ShatteredHopes
Sickness
Sinbad
Sin
Social Media
Speech
Spirits
Spiritual Warfare
Spirit
Staves
Stewardship
Story
Struggles
Study Group
Study
Style
Suffering
Sundays
Supernatural
Supplication
Surrender
Teacher
Teaching
Teleology
Temporal
Temptations
Temptation
Thankfulness
The Bible
The Great Commission
The Holy Scriptures
The Joker
The Local Church
The Lord's Supper
The Lord\'s Supper
The Lyons Region
The Sons of Korah
Theology
Thomas Brooks
Thorpe
Tim Challies
Torah
Total Depravity
Tradition
Transcendence
Trembling
Trials
Trouble
Trust
Truth
Tulip
Turner Classic Movies
Tyre
UFO
Unchanging
Understanding
Unexplained
Unseen Realm
Villians
Virtue
Wailing
Warning
War
Weakness
Wealth
Weeping
Western Music
Westminster Confession
Wisdom
Witch
Wonder
Words
Worship
Youngsters